Círdan, A Power Long Hidden

Cirdan by Quinton HooverLately, I’ve been pushing myself to build more thematic decks. With powerful new archetypes like Ents and Noldor, as well as the resurgence of older archetypes like Rohan, the game is in a great place when it comes to thematic deck-building. As someone who enjoys designing and tinkering, it is rewarding to build something that feels true to the source material and remains viable against many quests. Still, it can be nice to diverge from strictly theme-based decks and try a different approach. This deck is unabashedly a “combo deck” and is not intended to be particularly thematic.

To-the-Sea-to-the-SeaThanks to cards like To the Sea, To the Sea! and Lords of the Eldar, there will no doubt be some very powerful Noldor decks that field armies of impressive elves. The Ring of Power, Narya will fit right into such decks. The idea of readying allies multiple like Gildor Inglorion or ally Glorfindel is appealing to any deck. The fact that the ring also boosts their already impressive combat stats is almost too good to be true.

NaryaI’ll leave these ally-heavy decks for others to work out, and I have every confidence that such decks will be among the most powerful in the game. Although Círdan was a Teleri, the game has chosen to portray him as Noldor, and his powerful hero card will be yet another boon to that faction. With this deck, I have decided to focus on Círdan himself, rather than his ring or it’s accompanying strategy.

This is fitting in a way, as he gave the ring to Gandalf, when the Istari first showed up in Middle-earth. No small gesture for one of such noble lineage, Círdan was one of the few elves who did not seem burdened by the hubris of many of his brethren. Being able to willingly gift a ring of power to someone else has always struck me as an impressive level of generosity. Don’t let his beard  or generosity fool you, though, Círdan was no weakling.

“Take this ring, Master, for your labours will be heavy; but it will support you in the weariness that you have taken upon yourself. For this is the Ring of Fire, and with it you may rekindle hearts in a world that grows chill. But as for me, my heart is with the Sea, and I will dwell by the grey shores until the last ship sails. I will await you.”

He was among the eldar who fought alongside Gil-galad at the War of the Last Alliance. It was he, together with Elrond, who urged Isildur to destroy the One Ring. Until the end of the Third Age, he remained one of the wisest and most powerful of the Eldar in Middle-earth. This deck is an fun attempt to portray just how powerful Círdan can be, even when he is without his ring.

Elven-lightThe premise is simple, we will use the incredible draw engine of Erestor and Círdan, along with cards like Elven-light, to find our combo as quickly as possible. The combo in question is to attach Nor Am I A Stranger to Círdan and then give him Théoden’s sword, Herugrim. In most decks, building your entire strategy around a two card combo would represent a huge risk. Of all the factions, Noldor has by far the most powerful card-drawing capabilities, so it makes combo decks like this much less difficult to play.

Elwing's-FlightIn addition, the resource acceleration afforded by Arwen Undómiel will help to mitigate Erestor’s drawback. Having to discard your entire hand might at first seem like a terrible cost, but there are several tricks included that should make this much less of an issue. Besides discarding for Arwen, we have several cards which can be played from our discard pile. To add to this strategy, we have the new Spirit event from The Grey Havens – Elwing’s Flight – which becomes more powerful with each copy in the discard pile. Essentially, we are turning Erestor’s drawback into a strength.

Nor-am-I-a-StrangerOnce we have our combo in play, we won’t need any additional copies of our combo cards, so we can safely discard those as well. There are very few allies in the deck; the aforementioned ring is relegated to a sideboard card. Instead, we are looking to get maximum use of our  heroes, particularly the Shipwright.

His 4 willpower is impressive, but we want to benefit from this strength during more than just the quest phase. With the help of Light of Valinor (it feels good playing that card on someone other than Glorfindel), Círdan does not exhaust to quest. This, along with other Spirit-based readying effects, should ensure that he is standing tall when the combat phase arrives. That is where we have another chance to take advantage of his impressive willpower.

Herugrim-ToSHerugrim is an expensive card, and one that is typically only attached to Rohan heroes like Théoden or Éowyn. I wanted to have a bit of fun with this deck, and see how difficult it would be to make the sword work with a completely different hero. I won’t even attempt a narrative to explain how one of the oldest elves in Middle-earth, master of the havens, would come to wield the King of Rohan’s sword. Even a shape-changing bear finds some things inexplicable. After all, every deck tells a story, but not all stories make sense.

Star-BroochFrom a strategic standpoint, though, this deck can make all kinds of sense. Other then card-drawing effects, this deck is loaded to overflowing with willpower-boosting effects. I admit to a certain joy in discovering an actual use for cards like The Favor of the Lady and Star Brooch. When your hero gets to add his willpower to his attack, suddenly these cards don’t seem so inefficient. Unlike true combo cards, it’s not like they are dead without the sword, either. A worst case scenario with this deck is that you are relegated to one of the best questing decks every conceived.

Supplemental cards like Fair and Perilous can also help keep you alive while the combo gets setup. With 3 copies of key cards, do not be afraid to discard a copy of the combo early if absolutely necessary. As far as your opening hand is concerned, look for Nor Am I A Stranger, not the Sword. The title is a requirement before you can attach the weapon, and it will take a perfect hand (including A Good Harvest) to play both of them on the first turn. It’s easier to setup the combo in pieces, and get some less expensive support cards like Light of Valinor in play as well.

Galadhrim-WeaverWill of the West and Galadhrim Weaver allow you to get back critical cards if they find their way to your discard pile, but many of the cards in this deck are designed to be discarded. The Noldor discard archetype is a very different sort of deck because cards in your discard pile can as relevant to your strategy as the ones in your hand – often even more so. Silver Harp remains a staple, as there will be times when you have a card in your hand that you are not ready to discard.

This deck has almost nothing in the way of defense, and as powerful as Herugrim is it can only be used for a single attack each round. With these limitations and a starting threat of 31, this deck is not intended for solo play against most quests. Still, the level of willpower that you can quickly and easily bring to the table is impressive. Paired with a Dúnedain or other defensively-minded deck, this strategy can really shine. I look forward to the traditional Noldor decks that will emerge from The Grey Havens and Dream-chaser cycle. Still, it is fun to mix things up and try a very different strategy from time to time. Let me know what you think, and share your own combo deck ideas in the comments.

Círdan-the-ShipwrightErestor-ToRArwen-Undómiel

Heroes:
Círdan the Shipwright (The Grey Havens)
Erestor (The Treachery of Rhudaur)
Arwen Undómiel (The Dread Realm)

Allies: 10
Galadhrim Weaver x3 (The Treachery of Rhudaur)
Lindir x1 (The Battle of Carn Dûm)
Galdor of the Havens x1 (The Treachery of Rhudaur)
Glorfindel x1 (Flight of the Stormcaller)
Gildor Inglorion x1 (The Hills of Emyn Muil)
Gandalf x3 (Core Set)

Attachments: 20
The Favor of the Lady x2 (Core Set)
Light of Valinor x3 (Foundations of Stone)
Miruvor x2 (Shadow and Flame)
Nor Am I A Stranger x3 (Conflict at the Carrock)
Star Brooch x1 (The Lost Realm)
Protector of Lórien x1 (Core Set)
Silver Harp x3 (The Treachery of Rhudaur)
Unexpected Courage x1 (Core Set)
A Burning Brand x1 (Conflict at the Carrock)
Herugrim x3 (The Treason of Saruman)

Events: 19
Elrond’s Counsel x3 (The Watcher in the Water)
A Good Harvest x3 (The Steward’s Fear)
A Test of Will x2 (Core Set)
Elven-light x3 (The Dread Realm)
Fair and Perilous x2 (Across the Ettenmoors)
Will of the West x2 (Core Set)
Elwing’s Flight x3 (The Grey Havens)
Lords of the Eldar x1 (The Battle of Carn Dûm)

Side Quests: 1
Gather Information x1 (The Lost Realm)

Sideboard: 15
Galadriel x2 (The Road Darkens)
Elrond x2 (The Road Darkens)
To the Sea, To the Sea! x2 (The Grey Havens)
Asfaloth x2 (Foundations of Stone)
Narya x3 (The Grey Havens)
The Evening Star x3 (The Grey Havens)
Double Back x1 (Escape from Mount Gram)

This entry was posted in Combo, Fun, Metagame, Strategy and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

16 Responses to Círdan, A Power Long Hidden

  1. Nuregami says:

    Brilliant. I love Círdan, he’s one of my favourite characters, and I’m so glad to see him get a place in the lcg.

    It’s also worth pointing out that he fought against Morgoth in the First Age and is believed to be one of the first elves (not born but created by Eru). I think a quick calculation puts his age at over 14,000 years.

    • Beorn says:

      Thanks, Nuregami! I wanted to write about Círdan in more detail, but then the article would have been more about history than strategy. I’ll leave that in the more capable hands of others like Master of Lore.

  2. Very interesting. How much testing have you put into this deck and what kind of willpower numbers have you seen?

    • Beorn says:

      I’ve had The Grey Havens for less than a week now, so this deck is still in the initial testing phases. That said, the starting willpower is 9 (assuming another deck can deal with combat) so it comes out of the gate as one of the best questing decks I’ve ever used. The Weaver are obviously only questing, and all of the allies have good willpower, so the deck should be able to ramp up its questing over the course of the game. With so many cards that boost willpower (even Elrond’s Counsel) it should be easy to consistently quest for 12 or more by the mid-game. Again, this assumes that another deck is helping with the defense, but this deck is not designed to do everything.

  3. Gizlivadi says:

    I’ve been tinkering with that traditional Noldor solo deck with these very same heroes, and this article, even if it’s more combo oriented, helps a lot. Mine is still not an ally heavy deck per se (18 allies, 14 attachments and 18 events), but the idea is to use To the Sea! to play big allies such as Gildor, Glorfindel and Galdor, while also running the smaller allies in The Grey Havens, build a decent company of elves and pump them with Natya. Of course the deck uses most the discard events and outlets as well. Still have not tired it yet (waiting for Flight of the Stormcaller) but it looks pretty solid on paper. Having never used Erestor (or Círdan for that matter), I really wonder how many copies of Will of the West are actually necessary. Right now I have 3 copies but I don’t know how many times you actually use it.

    • Beorn says:

      If my experience with my other Erestor deck is any indication, you can probably get away with a single copy of Will of the West in these types of decks. The key for me is that I use it well before I have actually run out of cards in the deck. Typically, I will play Will of the West about half way through the game, with a bunch of free events and one-time use attachments in my discard pile (e.g. Elrond’s Counsel, Miruvor, Lembas, etc.). This gives me a whole new deck of useful cards to draw into. Now that we have The Grey Havens events that become more powerful with each copy in the discard, Will of the West seems even more dubious. This is why I am finding Galadhrim Weaver more useful in these decks; I can target specific cards for reuse without having to shuffle all of those events back into my deck. I am interested to check out your Noldor deck, feel free to link to it here in the comments!

  4. Gwaihir the Windlord says:

    Eowyn was usurped as the game’s most solid quester, and Aragorn watched from the sidelines while the FFG staff hurried to errata Herugrim. This is a great deck; I can’t wait to try it out. These combos are extremely creative and will change the normal uses of some old favorites.

  5. ransomman1 says:

    Nice! A 7+ attack Cirdan is nothing to sneeze at! Erestor just makes so many awesome shenanigans possible! Ally Glorfindel is also very cool.

    When I opened grey havens I was excited by all of the possibilities I saw, but mostly by Narya. I was a little sad that while Narya granted the leadership icon, there were seemingly not a ton of leadership options for Noldor. I then realized that Leadership Hero Faramir has the same game plan as Narya! So I began my Trisphere journey.

    Here it is for your viewing pleasure: http://seastan.github.io/#/deck/id:O7WGy9bV0N

    I’ve found that Lindon Navigator is actually a superstar in this deck, oddly enough… especially with sailing tests! She can just get so much done. She’s actually an integral part of the card draw engine because without Lore Hero Erestor, you need a consistent way to be able to keep recurring Elven-light from the trash. She gives you a perfect excuse to trash Elven-light every turn (not to mention To the Sea!).

    Faramir and Narya also give us access to the steward and to A Very Good Tale, both of which make this deck… well a lot of decks… sing.

    I can talk for a while about the cool things in this deck but I’d just be patting myself on the back!

    It ain’t perfect though. I’d say it can be a little tricky to get going, and many of the Allies are wimpy. So even though you can muster some ridiculous willpower with the (mostly) Noldor swarm, and also ready up to three allies a turn for combat, some direct damage has the potential to wipe out your army and you’re feelin’ sad. Also, I wish there was a tad more attack across the board… on the other hand, with Arwen and Narya, characters with 2 or 3 defense are now blocking with 4 or 5 defense!

    Anyway… I’ve rambled enough. I think it’s a fun twist on the Noldor mechanics!

    • Beorn says:

      That deck looks like a lot of fun. I agree about Lindon Navigator – that card is perfectly suited for helping with Sailing tests, and is another way to make use of cards in a Noldor deck. Once Ally Glorfindel is released it should fit right into this deck, and it will help provide another strong ally to use with Narya. It is exciting to see this archetype evolve.

  6. TalesfromtheCards says:

    I’ve wanted to experiment with Nor Am I A Stranger/Herugrim for awhile, but never got around to it. Cirdan is definitely a great choice to steal Theoden’s sword! Actually, I’m pretty sure he won it from Theoden fair and square in the Great Middle-Earth Beard-off of 3018.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s